Can a white cloud minnow live with fancy goldfish?
Edited by Marin Hale · last reviewed November 14, 2026
Sometimes, with care, in 20+ gallons. No in 5 or 10 gallons.
White cloud minnows and fancy goldfish can share a tank of 20+ gallons, with care. Adult fancy goldfish may eat small white cloud minnows.
Plan on a tank of at least 20 gallons for both.
| White cloud minnow | Fancy goldfish | |
|---|---|---|
| Tolerates | 64–72°F | 65–74°F |
| Adult size | 1.6 in | 6–8 in |
| Temperament | Peaceful | Peaceful |
| Smallest tank | 10 gallons | 20 gallons |
| Keep at least | 6 together | — |
Water temperature: Both are comfortable at 65–72°F.
What makes it risky
- Size and appetite. Adult fancy goldfish may eat small white cloud minnows.
How to make it work
Skip this pairing unless you can give the minnows a heavily planted tank of at least 20 gallons, with a school of at least 6 white clouds and dense plant cover at the top and middle where they feel safe. Choose a fancy goldfish that is clearly full-grown, because adults at 6–8 inches can swallow 1.6-inch minnows. Make sure the tank has passed the readiness check before either goes in.
Tank size and numbers
| 5 gal | 10 gal | 20 gal | 29 gal | 40 gal | 55 gal | 75 gal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No | No | Maybe | Maybe | Maybe | Maybe | Maybe |
Below 20 gallons there isn’t room for both. “Maybe” means the tank is big enough, but the risk above still applies. Try your numbers in the stocking calculator
Introducing them, and what to watch
- Set up and cycle the tank first, and let the plants grow in so the minnows have thick cover near the surface before any fish go in.
- Check that the water suits both fish: aim for about 65–72°F, pH between 6.8 and 8.0, and hardness of 8–18 dGH.
- Add the school of 6 or more white cloud minnows first and let them settle for a week or two, so they learn the tank and its hiding spots.
- Feed the goldfish well, then add it to the tank. Stay nearby for the first few hours, since goldfish feed by mouthing and gulping anything that fits.
- Feed both groups at the same time each day, scattering some food at the surface for the minnows while the goldfish feeds lower down.
Warning signs in the first weeks
- Minnows vanishing from the school with no body found. This suggests the goldfish is eating them.
- The goldfish repeatedly chasing or cornering a minnow, or a minnow pinned against the glass or decor.
- Torn or split fins, missing scales, wounds or bite marks on any fish. Separate the fish at once if you see any of these.
- Minnows hiding all day in the plants, refusing food, or clamping their fins instead of schooling in open water.
Plan B: If any minnow is injured, missing, or repeatedly chased or cornered, separate the fish immediately by moving the goldfish or the minnows to their own tank. After that, keep them apart: the size gap is built in, so a goldfish tank on its own is the safer choice, and the white clouds do well in a separate tank at 20 gallons or more.
Safer tank mates for a white cloud minnow
How we reached this verdict
| Pass | Water temperature | Both are comfortable at 65–72°F. |
|---|---|---|
| Pass | pH | Both are comfortable at pH 6.8–8.0. |
| Pass | Water hardness | Both handle water hardness of 8–18 dGH. |
| Watch | Size and appetite | Adult fancy goldfish may eat small white cloud minnows. |
| Pass | Fins | Neither nips fins, so the long fins of fancy goldfish are safe. |
| Pass | Temperament | Both are peaceful. |
Sources
(9 references)
Verdicts come from both fish’s cross-checked care facts and our compatibility rules. Each fact’s quotes are on the care pages: White cloud minnow · Fancy goldfish.
- White Cloud Mountain minnow (en.wikipedia.org)
- Tanichthys albonubes (Seriously Fish) (seriouslyfish.com)
- How to set up a White Cloud biotope (practicalfishkeeping.co.uk)
- You Need to Know About White Cloud Mountain Minnow ... (petsnurturing.com)
- White Cloud Mountain Minnow | Ultimate Care Guide (fishlaboratory.com)
- Goldfish (en.wikipedia.org)
- Goldfish Care Guide (aqueon.com)
- How to look after fancy goldfish - OATA (ornamentalfish.org)
- The Carassius auratus Known As Oranda (qualitymarine.com)
Verdicts come from cross-checked species data and our compatibility rules. How verdicts work · Fancy goldfish care





